Dr. Anila Ali Speaks Truth to Power at NYC Anti-Mamdani Rally — When Muslim Voices Stand with Jews — the Islamist Left Responds with “Jahannam”
At a landmark interfaith protest outside Gracie Mansion, Muslim women’s rights leader Dr. Anila Ali called on Jewish New Yorkers to demand Mayor Mamdani’s resignation — and declared that an attack on Jewish religious freedom is an attack on Muslim religious freedom. Then NYC Councilwoman Shahana Hanif responded by condemning the Muslim organizers to “Jahannam.”
NEW YORK CITY — In one of the most striking acts of interfaith solidarity New York has seen in recent years, Dr. Anila Ali — Muslim women’s rights activist, founder and CEO of the American Muslim & Multifaith Women’s Empowerment Council (AMMWEC) — took the stage at the Protest Zohran Mamdani rally outside Gracie Mansion and delivered a speech that shook the crowd and is now reverberating across the city. Her message was direct and uncompromising: being Muslim does not give any mayor — or anyone — the right to make Jewish New Yorkers feel unsafe. And she called on Jewish New Yorkers to demand Mamdani’s resignation.
The rally, organized by EndJewHatred and held one block from Gracie Mansion, specifically featured Muslim speakers — a powerful signal that the fight against Mamdani’s Islamist brand of politics is not only a Jewish cause, but a Muslim one. What followed, however, exposed exactly why this protest was necessary: NYC Democratic Socialist Councilwoman Shahana Hanif responded to the rally by posting on X that she hoped the Muslim organizers would be condemned to Jahannam — the Islamic equivalent of hell.
Dr. Ali’s Speech: “Saying I’m a Muslim Does Not Give You Permission”
Standing before the crowd gathered outside Gracie Mansion, Dr. Ali delivered a speech that combined deep personal faith with fierce civic courage — addressing Mayor Mamdani directly, invoking the memory of 9/11, and drawing the sharpest possible connection between Jewish and Muslim religious freedom.
“When the religious freedom of Jewish people is violated, the religious freedom of Muslims is also under attack.”
— Dr. Anila Ali, Founder & CEO, AMMWECDr. Ali to Fox News: “He Targets the Jewish People”
Earlier on Tuesday, before the rally, Dr. Ali spoke with Fox News Digital, elaborating on why she has made opposing Mayor Mamdani a central cause and describing what she sees as his Islamist supporters’ hijacking of the Muslim faith.
Dr. Anila Ali — Fox News Digital Interview, Tuesday
Ali described herself as part of a post-9/11 movement of “moderate Muslims” who believe that Islam is wholly compatible with life in America — and who refuse to allow political Islamism to define their faith in the eyes of their fellow citizens. Her image of a perfect protest, she told Fox News Digital, was one of interfaith unity — demonstrators declaring together that “this is America.”
Councilwoman Hanif Condemns Muslim Protesters to “Jahannam”
What should have been a moment that prompted serious political reflection instead produced one of the most alarming responses to date from the Mamdani camp. NYC Democratic Socialist Councilwoman Shahana Hanif — best known for her frequent anti-Israel remarks — chose not to engage with the substance of the protesters’ concerns. Instead, she reached for a theological condemnation, posting on X that she hoped the Muslim organizers of the protest would be condemned to “Jahannam” — the Islamic equivalent of hell.
Hanif reposted two advertisements for the “Protest Zohran Mamdani” demonstration that specifically featured Muslim speakers — then raged in a post on X:
Jahannam is the Islamic equivalent of hell. Rather than offering a political argument, a legal framework, or a reasoned response to the protesters’ concerns about Jewish New Yorkers’ safety, the lefty Brooklyn lawmaker chose a religious condemnation — issuing what amounts to a fatwa against Muslim women who dared to stand with the Jewish community.
⚠ Why This Moment Matters
Hanif’s post is not merely offensive — it is revealing. It demonstrates precisely what Dr. Ali and the rally’s organizers argued: that when Muslim voices dare to stand with Jewish New Yorkers against Mayor Mamdani’s brand of political Islam, the response from the Islamist left is not a counter-argument. It is a religious condemnation — a theological weapon deployed against fellow Muslims who choose conscience over conformity. As Dr. Ali put it: “This is not a political position. This is what we need to handle.”
“Islam Has Not Come to New York City”
Dr. Ali also addressed a broader claim circulating in Mamdani’s orbit — the suggestion, made by at least one of his supporters, that “Islam has come to New York” because a Muslim has been elected mayor. Ali responded with sharp clarity: the election of a Muslim mayor does not mean that Islamic governance has arrived in New York. That framing, she said, is not only wrong — it is terrifying in the context of September 11, 2001.
The Significance: Muslims Standing with Jews in New York
The Protest Zohran Mamdani rally — and Dr. Ali’s speech at it — represents something genuinely historic in New York civic life. For the first time in recent memory, an organized group of Muslim leaders and activists has publicly and loudly stood with the Jewish community against a sitting Muslim mayor — not despite their faith, but because of it. Dr. Ali’s argument is theological as much as political: genuine Islam, she insists, does not permit the harassment of Jewish people. Genuine Islam does not look away while religious freedom is violated. And genuine Muslim leadership does not respond to dissent by condemning fellow Muslims to hell.
Shahana Hanif’s “Jahannam” post proved the protesters’ point more powerfully than any speech could have. When the only answer to Muslim women standing with Jewish New Yorkers is a religious curse — rather than a policy argument, a legal rebuttal, or even a simple acknowledgment of concerns — it tells New York exactly what kind of politics Mayor Mamdani and his allies represent.
Faith & Freedom News commends Dr. Anila Ali and all interfaith participants at Tuesday’s rally for their courage, their clarity, and their commitment to a New York where every faith can be practiced freely and safely.
About The Author
Discover more from Faith & Freedom News - FFN
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
