MKM
Muhammad Kashif Mirza
Child & Minority Rights Advocate · Development Practitioner · Karachi, Pakistan · @qashifmirza
Guest Op-Ed

Every twelfth of June, the world pauses to acknowledge a problem that ought not to exist. The World Day Against Child Labour is not a ceremonial occasion. It is a prompt — directed at governments, legislators, employers, and societies — to reckon honestly with the distance between their formal commitments and the lived reality of millions of children. For Pakistan, that distance remains vast, and the reckoning, overdue.

The most widely cited estimate holds that approximately 3.3 million Pakistani children aged five to fourteen are trapped in child labour — a figure derived from the 1996 National Child Labour Survey and still quoted by major international bodies. Its persistence as the reference point is itself an indictment: nearly three decades have passed without a comprehensive national survey to replace it. More recent data from the Pakistan Labour Force Survey 2017–18, cited by the ILO, indicates that 13.7% of children aged ten to seventeen were engaged in child labour, with 5.4% involved in hazardous forms. These are not abstractions. They are children who begin the working day before their peers open a textbook.

3.3M Children in child labour
(ages 5–14, est.)
26M Out-of-school children
in Pakistan (2024)
1.6M Children in child labour
in Sindh alone

The Scale: Province by Province

Provincial surveys bring the aggregate into sharper focus. The Punjab Child Labour Survey 2019–20 found a prevalence rate of 13.4% among children aged five to fourteen, rising to 16.9% when hazardous work is included across the five-to-seventeen cohort. In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the 2022–23 survey found that 11.1% of children aged five to seventeen were economically active — with 80% of those classified as being in child labour and 73.8% working under hazardous conditions. In Sindh, a peer-reviewed study published in Stats in 2024 found that approximately 20% of children aged five to seventeen were engaged in child labour. The Sindh Child Labour Survey 2022–24 identified more than 1.6 million children aged five to seventeen in child labour in that province alone. In Balochistan, the first-ever district-level survey — conducted in 2023–24 — recorded an overall prevalence of 3.7%, climbing to 9.8% among adolescents aged fourteen to seventeen.

Agriculture remains the dominant employer of working children, absorbing 69.4% of those aged five to fourteen — a proportion that has barely shifted from the 74% recorded in 1996. Less visible but equally grave is the exploitation embedded in domestic work. A scoping study commissioned under the Asia Regional Child Labour Project, funded by the UK’s Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, found that one in every four households in Pakistan employs a child in domestic work, predominantly girls aged ten to fourteen. In Sindh’s agricultural sector, reports estimate that approximately 700,000 children work as bonded labourers, trapped by the peshgi system through which employers advance cash to families, binding the entire household — children included — to servitude until the debt is discharged.

The child harvesting cotton in interior Sindh, the girl washing dishes in a Lahore employer’s kitchen before dawn, the Christian boy mixing mortar beside his parents at a Punjab brick kiln with no school in his past and none in his foreseeable future — none of them are unprotected for want of laws.

— Muhammad Kashif Mirza

Minority Children: Compounded Vulnerability

Within this landscape of generalised exploitation, children from religious minority communities occupy a distinctly compounded position of vulnerability. Pakistan’s National Commission on the Rights of the Child, in its report titled “Situation Analysis of Children from Minority Religions in Pakistan” — funded by UNICEF and released in August 2025 — identified child labour as the most widespread issue among minority communities, driven by intergenerational poverty and the near-total exclusion of minority families from educational and economic opportunity. The report documents that bonded labour in brick kilns and agriculture disproportionately concentrates Christian and Hindu children, whose families have few alternative livelihood pathways due to systemic discrimination. NCRC Chairperson Ayesha Raza Farooq acknowledged that progress in addressing minority child rights has been “dismal,” attributing this explicitly to “fragmented efforts, lack of coordination, and limited political will.”

The Brick Kiln Disparity

Religious minorities constitute approximately 5% of Pakistan’s population, yet the proportion of religious minorities among brick kiln workers is often as high as 50%, particularly in Punjab and Sindh. Approximately 60% of workers living and working in brick kilns are Christians — a community that makes up around 2% of the national population. A survey by the Trust for Democratic Education and Accountability found that 72% of brick kiln workers have children working alongside them. Among child respondents in brick kilns, more than half began working between the ages of eight and ten, and over 60% have never attended any school.

The educational exclusion of minority children reinforces this cycle. The US Department of Labor’s 2023 Findings on the Worst Forms of Child Labor in Pakistan notes that non-Muslim and Ahmadi Muslim children are sometimes denied school enrolment because of their religious identity. Children from minority ethnic groups — native speakers of Sindhi, Pashtun, Saraiki, Balochi, and others — face additional barriers because instruction is delivered in Urdu and English, languages many minority children do not command at home. The NCRC report found that minority children who do attend school face persistent social discrimination from both teachers and classmates: they are hesitant to sit at the front of classrooms, reluctant to ask questions, and denied access to shared facilities. The cumulative effect is predictable — isolation, below-average academic performance, and early dropout, all of which feed directly into the labour market.

◆   ◆   ◆

Laws That Exist and Systems That Don’t

What sustains this system — for all children — is not an absence of laws. Pakistan has ratified ILO Convention No. 138 on minimum age, ILO Convention No. 182 on the worst forms of child labour, and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. The Constitution prohibits the employment of children under fourteen in factories, mines, and hazardous employment under Article 11(3), and Article 25-A mandates free and compulsory education for all children aged five to sixteen. The Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act of 1992 prohibits the peshgi system outright.

These commitments exist on paper. They coexist, in practice, with conditions that make child labour a rational household survival strategy. The national child labour baseline records that the primary reasons parents permit their children to work are assisting in a family small business, cited by 69%, and supplementing household income, cited by 28%. An out-of-school crisis that affected an estimated 22.8 million children in 2022, rising to nearly 26 million by 2024, reflects the scale of the educational system’s failure to compete with economic necessity.

Academic Impact: The Evidence

A peer-reviewed study published in Prospects found a consistent negative association between child labour and foundational learning among children aged twelve to fourteen in Pakistan. Engagement in economic labour was associated with a 0.28 unit decrease in foundational reading scores and a 0.15 unit decrease in numeracy scores. Researchers identified an intensive labour threshold at approximately 2.5 hours of work per day — beyond which academic performance drops sharply and the probability of returning to school diminishes substantially. For minority children already excluded by discrimination and language barriers, this threshold is crossed earlier and its consequences are deeper.

The gap between legal intent and enforcement is, in part, an arithmetic problem. Pakistan requires at least 4,388 labour inspectors to cover a labour force of 65.8 million; current staffing falls far short of that figure. In Punjab in 2023, inspectors conducted over 85,000 child labour inspections, resulting in 87 arrests; 8,580 targeted brick kiln inspections identified 771 violations and produced 34 arrests. The disproportion between scale and outcome reflects structural under-resourcing rather than a lack of effort. Compounding this is a fundamental blind spot in the legal architecture: virtually every major labour statute excludes informal agriculture, home-based work, and domestic enterprise — precisely the sectors where the overwhelming majority of child labourers, and virtually all minority child labourers, are found.

Pakistan possesses the legal vocabulary of a state committed to child rights. The honest accounting is this: ratifications and constitutional articles are necessary but not sufficient. They are unprotected because the systems that should translate law into protection have been chronically underfunded, institutionally fragmented, and structured to see only the formal economy.

— Muhammad Kashif Mirza

The Reforms Required

The 2022 monsoon floods — which damaged 27,000 schools and affected 230,000 students in Sindh alone — illustrate a further fragility: climate shocks deepen household debt and destroy educational infrastructure simultaneously, and minority families, with the least financial resilience, bear a disproportionate share of these cascading consequences. The path forward, however, is identifiable.

Provincial assemblies should standardise the minimum employment age at sixteen, closing the legal gap with Article 25-A’s compulsory education mandate. Labour inspection frameworks must extend to informal agriculture, domestic work, and home-based industries. Birth registration — historically documented at only 34% of children under five nationally in the 2012–13 Pakistan Demographic and Health Survey — must be completed at scale through NADRA partnerships, ensuring every child has enforceable legal identity before they can be exploited. Social safety nets, particularly the Benazir Income Support Programme, must be tied directly to school enrolment. And enforcement of the Bonded Labour System (Abolition) Act must be substantively resourced, with specific attention to the brick kiln and agricultural sectors where minority communities are disproportionately concentrated.

Invisibility as System Design

For children at the intersection of poverty and minority identity, invisibility to the state is not incidental. It is the system working as it was never reformed to prevent. The majority of bonded labourers in Pakistan’s brick kilns are drawn from scheduled caste Hindus, Christians, and other marginalised communities — as documented by Anti-Slavery International. Their exclusion from formal labour market protections, quality schooling, and social safety nets is structural, not accidental.

On this World Day Against Child Labour, the honest accounting for Pakistan is this: the country possesses the legal vocabulary of a state committed to child rights. What it has not yet built are the systems, resources, and political will to make that vocabulary real for the most vulnerable children within its borders — the ones whose invisibility to the state is not a gap in coverage, but the predictable outcome of systems designed to protect what they can see, and structured never to look where the need is greatest.