FAITH & FREEDOM NEWS
Truth · Liberty · Global Faith Affairs
Opinion · Minorities & EducationFor children from Pakistan’s religious minorities, exclusion at school is often not one big event but many small ones. Equal access to education, writes Muhammad Kashif Mirza, means every child can learn with dignity.
For kids from Pakistan’s religious minorities, being excluded at school isn’t always a big deal. It can be the small things: a lesson that doesn’t recognise their religion, a teacher who simply doesn’t take any religious abuse seriously, a subject they can’t really get out of, or a textbook which either doesn’t have their community at all or only has a very marginal presence. They may well go to lessons and sit their exams and still get the message that ‘we’ in the classroom don’t include them.
This isn’t just a matter of courtesy or interfaith harmony. It’s about equal access to education, freedom of belief and a child’s right to develop an identity without being humiliated.
A study from the DARE Research Centre published on 2 October 2026 provides very direct evidence. It was a qualitative study across all four provinces, involving children aged 14–16 from Christian, Hindu, Sikh, Kalasha, Parsi, Buddhist and anonymised minority communities as well as teachers and school leaders. The study used interviews, focus groups and picture prompt storytelling to explore school practice, peer relationships and children’s aspirations.
The findings don’t establish how frequently each experience occurs across Pakistan. The study used purposive sampling and wasn’t designed to produce a nationally representative prevalence estimate. It does however record a range of experiences which are often not captured in official statistics. Education was seen by the children as a route to opportunity. They also reported:
Supportive teachers and cross-faith friendships were a positive. Staff silence and a lack of institutional response made the experience of exclusion much worse.
The National Commission on the Rights of the Child came to a similar conclusion in its State of Children in Pakistan 2025 report. It found that prejudice, social exclusion and fear of harassment are all issues which minority students are more likely to report in public schools. Textbooks are noted to provide very little representation of religious diversity and in some cases even contain negative depictions. The Commission sees educational disadvantage as the result of a confluence of factors such as poverty, caste, gender and location. Minority girls in particular may be constrained by mobility issues, domestic responsibilities, early marriage and fears for their safety in relation to the school.
Religious identity doesn’t work in isolation. A Hindu girl from a poor SC background in rural Sindh will face a very different set of challenges to a Christian boy in an urban school, a Sikh kid in KPK or a Kalasha child in Chitral. To simply lump all ‘minority children’ together is to obscure the differences. The evidence shows that there are overlapping disadvantages and the responses need to be ones that are appropriate to the local context.
Pakistan’s Constitution is not silent on the matter.
Pakistan’s Constitution
- Article 20 provides for the right to profess, practise and propagate religion subject to law, public order and morality.
- Article 22(1) provides that no student shall be compelled to receive religious instruction or to participate in any worship or ceremony of a religion other than their own.
- Article 22(3)(b) protects admission to institutions funded by the State against discrimination on grounds of religion and caste alone.
- Article 25A requires the State to provide free and compulsory education to children between the ages of 5 and 16.
The Convention on the Rights of the Child, which Pakistan ratified in 1990, provides for these protections too.
Convention on the Rights of the Child
- Article 2 prohibits discrimination, including on the grounds of the religion of the child or of the parent.
- Article 14 guarantees the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion.
- Articles 28 and 29 enshrine education as a right and as a means of developing respect for human rights, for cultural identity and for the rights of other religious groups.
- Article 30 protects the right of a child from a minority group to enjoy his or her own culture, to practice his or her own religion and to use his or her own language in community with others.
The policy landscape has shifted. The National Curriculum Council has stated that the National Curriculum of Pakistan 2022–23 will provide Religious Education from Grade 1, on the basis of the child’s religion, for the seven minority religions of Christianity, Sikhism, Buddhism, Hinduism, Baha’ism, Kalasha and Zoroastrianism. That is a very significant policy commitment and should be recognised. The Council has also made it clear that the provinces will be respected in their autonomy and will be required to go through their own legal processes to implement the policy.
A curriculum announcement is not in itself a working classroom provision. You need textbooks that are actually available, trained teachers, a timetable of lessons, appropriate assessments and a clear process to ensure that children are not being forced to study another religion. The DARE-RC findings are rather more recent and suggest that the issues of curriculum visibility and the experience of compulsory religious subjects have by no means gone away. The issue is now not just what has been approved, it’s what children can actually access in their schools.
Nor does a standalone Religious Education subject in any way resolve the wider issue of representation. A child’s community should not only be present in the curriculum when the textbook gets to religion. History, literature, civics and social studies all play a part in defining who is part of the national story. If minority communities are not there in those subjects, or are only there in a stereotypical manner rather than as a result of their actual history and contribution, then a separate Religious Studies lesson is not going to fix the problem. Inclusion means that Pakistan’s diversity is part of its shared history, not something that is just dropped in as an afterthought.
Classroom culture is just as important. The NCRC report makes it clear that there is still a significant under-representation of members of minority communities in the public teaching workforce and that the grievance mechanisms in place for dealing with discrimination are extremely weak. A teacher who hears a slur and does nothing is not a neutral observer. If there is no confidential way of making a complaint, no anti-bullying procedure and no accountability for the repetition of such incidents, the child is left to deal with the problem which has been created by the adults.
That said, it would be wrong to assume that every teacher or every school is in fact discriminatory. The DARE-RC study does point to the protective effect of supportive teachers and friendships across lines of religion. Those are the examples of a positive school culture.
-
Implementation
Provincial education departments should publish which schools are offering each of the approved Religious Education curricula, whether textbooks are available, whether trained teachers have been appointed and how pupils are being assessed. Where a school is unable to offer a subject due to small numbers, the authorities should arrange a practical alternative rather than simply go back on the subject and leave pupils without a subject appropriate to their faith. Parents and children should be given clear information about their rights under Article 22.
-
Breadth of the Curriculum
Textbook boards should scrutinise the compulsory subjects for any inaccurate, exclusionary or derogatory content and should publish their review process. They should actively involve teachers from the communities they represent. Teacher training should address religious and caste-based prejudice and how to respond to bullying. Schools should have confidential reporting and referral arrangements in place which do not put the child at risk of retaliation.
-
Evidence
The NCRC’s 2025 report records 384,484 public sector minority child enrolments in Sindh, with no breakdown by education level or by gender. You can’t really monitor who is progressing, who is dropping out or where girls are at a disadvantage without privacy-protected data. The data has to be used to improve services, not just to label the children.
World Children’s Day 2026 has the theme “My Day, My Rights, My Future.” That is a very practical test when applied to minority children in Pakistan. Can a child go through the school day and just learn, without having to hide or justify their identity? Can they have an education that acknowledges their religion and reflects the society in which they live? Can they envisage a future in which their religion or their caste doesn’t in any way restrict the choices they have?
In Closing
Inclusion is visible in the lesson plan, the textbook, the teacher’s response, the subject a child is allowed to study and the complaint that is taken seriously. The right to education is not fulfilled by attendance alone. It is fulfilled when every child can learn with dignity, participate without fear and recognise themselves as an equal part of the country they are being taught to build.
This is an opinion article.
About The Author
Discover more from Faith & Freedom News - FFN
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.