The ceasefire between Israel and Hamas, spanning nearly two months, has collapsed, with Israel resuming airstrikes on Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ) targets in Gaza this week. Mainstream news outlets swiftly reported that Israel had broken the ceasefire, framing it as the aggressor unwilling to pursue peace. However, this narrative misrepresents the reality: the ceasefire disintegrated due to Hamas’s refusal to release remaining Israeli hostages and its continued violations of the agreement.
Why the Ceasefire Failed
The ceasefire’s first phase ended on March 1 as originally planned, aimed at securing the release of hostages held by Hamas. Israel sought to extend this phase to retrieve more captives, agreeing to two mediation proposals. Hamas rejected both, refusing to free the remaining 59 hostages. Far from breaking the ceasefire, Israel refrained from military action for 20 days after March 1, hoping Hamas would comply. When it became clear Hamas would not, the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) resumed strikes to dismantle terrorist infrastructure and pressure Hamas into releasing all hostages.
Hamas further undermined the ceasefire by launching rockets at Israeli cities and planning terror attacks during the pause. These actions violated the agreement’s terms, as Hamas exploited the lull to rearm, rebuild tunnels, and prepare future assaults. Additionally, Hamas delayed providing names of hostages slated for release, disrupting the process, and staged propaganda-driven ceremonies with released captives, breaching the ceasefire’s spirit.
Israel’s military operations target Hamas and PIJ—not Gaza’s civilians—with the objectives of neutralizing the terrorist threat and securing the hostages’ freedom. Had Hamas released the captives, fighting would not have resumed.
Media Missteps and Misinformation
Following the airstrikes, the Hamas-run Gaza Ministry of Health released casualty figures, prompting headlines claiming hundreds of deaths. Many outlets failed to clarify the ministry’s Hamas affiliation or its practice of conflating civilian and combatant casualties, echoing a pattern of incomplete reporting.
This mirrors the October 2023 Al-Ahli hospital incident, where initial reports—citing the same ministry—alleged 500 deaths from an Israeli airstrike. Investigations later confirmed a misfired PIJ rocket struck a parking lot, not the hospital, with a far lower death toll. The misreporting fueled diplomatic fallout, including Jordan’s King Abdullah II canceling a meeting with President Biden, and U.S. lawmakers like Rep. Rashida Tlaib (D-MI) wrongly blaming Israel despite evidence.
Jewish Insider Executive Editor Melissa Weiss questions why news organizations repeatedly rely on Hamas’s unverifiable statistics. The absence of a free press in Gaza, coupled with Israeli restrictions on journalist access, forces dependence on potentially biased sources. Social media and some outlets, including The Washington Post—currently investigating an employee’s pro-Hamas posts—have been accused of amplifying anti-Israel narratives. Axel Springer’s Martin Varsavsky also criticized Politico for publishing an Associated Press piece reliant on Hamas data.
The Bigger Picture
Hamas has been accused of manipulating humanitarian aid narratives, countered only recently by Israel’s COGAT providing official truck statistics in spring 2024. Weiss argues that Hamas weaponizes the press to advance its agenda, exploiting the challenges of conflict-zone reporting. The Al-Ahli incident underscores the stakes: unchecked misinformation shapes diplomacy and public perception.
Seventeen months into the war, Weiss notes the persistent “largely anti-Israel media narrative” and calls for greater journalistic rigor. As the conflict continues, the ceasefire’s collapse highlights the need for accurate, contextual reporting free from partisan sway. The truth remains: Hamas’s actions—holding hostages and violating terms—triggered the renewed fighting, not Israel’s pursuit of peace.
About The Author
Discover more from FFN
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
